Understanding God’s Role in Evil: Divine Plan and Human Free Will

Explore how God’s sovereignty and human free will coexist and why evil is part of His divine plan.

Understanding how God’s sovereignty and human free will coexist has always sparked deep theological discussions. The core question revolves around how a sovereign God, who ordains everything, can coexist with human choice and the presence of evil. Let’s dive into these concepts, breaking down how God’s ordination works without infringing on human responsibility or His holiness. By looking at key biblical examples, we’ll see how God’s grand plan incorporates human actions, even sinful ones, to fulfill His greater purposes and showcase His wisdom and goodness.

What Does “Ordained” Mean? When we say God ordains something, we mean He has planned and determined its occurrence according to His divine will and purpose. This spans everything in the universe, from massive cosmic events to the tiniest details of our lives.

God’s Sovereignty Explained God’s sovereignty means He has supreme power and authority over all creation. He controls everything that happens; nothing occurs outside His will. However, this doesn’t mean He directly causes every event, especially sinful actions. Instead, He permits them within the framework of His greater plan.

God’s Ordination and Human Free Will Understanding God’s sovereignty means recognizing that it coexists with human free will. While God has a predetermined plan, humans still make real choices that carry real consequences. This coexistence maintains the reality of human responsibility and moral choices.

God is Not the Author of Sin Although God ordains all events, including those involving evil actions, He is not the author of sin. This means God doesn’t directly cause sin or tempt anyone to sin. Instead, He permits sin to occur as part of His sovereign plan, using even sinful actions to fulfill His purposes without being morally responsible for the sin itself.

Examples to Illustrate These Concepts Example 1: Joseph and His Brothers One vivid example is Joseph’s story in Genesis. Joseph’s brothers, driven by jealousy, sold him into slavery—a sinful act. But through various events, Joseph rose to power in Egypt and saved his family from famine. Joseph explained to his brothers, “You intended to harm me, but God intended it for good to accomplish what is now being done, the saving of many lives” (Genesis 50:20, NIV). This shows that while his brothers meant evil, God had a greater plan for good.

Example 2: The Crucifixion of Jesus Another profound example is Jesus’s crucifixion. According to Christian belief, this was the most unjust act in history, yet it was part of God’s plan for humanity’s salvation. In Acts 2:23, Peter says, “This man was handed over to you by God’s deliberate plan and foreknowledge; and you, with the help of wicked men, put him to death by nailing him to the cross” (NIV). This illustrates that while sinful human actions carried out the crucifixion, it was part of God’s sovereign plan for a greater purpose—redemption and salvation.

Human Responsibility and Secondary Causes God’s sovereignty also involves secondary causes. While God ordains ultimate outcomes, human actions and natural laws are immediate causes. For example, planting a seed grows into a plant due to natural laws God established. Similarly, when someone sins, it’s their choice and action, even though God permits it as part of His overarching plan.

God’s Purposes and Human Understanding The doctrine of God’s sovereignty and the ordination of events, including evil, should be approached with humility and reverence. It’s a complex and mysterious part of theology that leads to a deeper trust in God’s wisdom and goodness, even when we don’t fully understand His ways.

Bringing it All Together In summary, understanding God’s sovereignty and the existence of evil involves several key points:

  • Ordination: God has a sovereign plan that includes all events.
  • Human Responsibility: Humans are responsible for their sinful actions within God’s ordained plan.
  • God’s Holiness: God is not the author of sin and doesn’t directly cause sinful actions.
  • Greater Purpose: God’s ordination of events, including sin, serves a greater purpose aligned with His holy and wise plan.
  • Biblical Examples: Stories like Joseph’s and Jesus’s crucifixion show how God can use human actions, even sinful ones, to achieve His good purposes.

Grasping the relationship between God’s sovereignty and the existence of evil is crucial for understanding Christian theology. This balance affirms that while God ordains all events, He is not the author of sin. Human beings are responsible for their actions, and God’s greater purposes are fulfilled through their choices.

By examining examples like Joseph’s story and Jesus’s crucifixion, we see that even the most unjust actions can be used by God to bring about good and fulfill His divine will. These narratives provide insights into the coexistence of divine sovereignty and human free will, offering comfort that God’s plan is at work even amidst evil. This understanding encourages believers to trust in God’s wisdom, knowing that every event in their lives, good or bad, is part of His sovereign plan. It invites us to approach the mysteries of God’s will with humility, recognizing that His ways are higher than ours. Ultimately, it leads to a deeper faith and appreciation of God’s providential care over all creation.